Slideshow image

Our church is excited to once again participate in the upcoming Citywide Garage Sale—and we need your help to make it a success! This event is an important fundraiser, and with a little extra care in what we collect, we can make it more effective than ever. 

This year, we are being intentional about the items we accept. Rather than a large quantity of small or hard-to-sell items, we are focusing on higher-value, gently used items that will sell easily. Think quality over quantity.

Examples of items we gladly welcome include:

  • Bikes (we already have two great mountain bike sets!)
  • Furniture or outdoor items in good condition (like lawn chairs)
  • Household sets (such as a complete dish set, not single pieces)
  • Tools or specialty items (like a marine-grade winch or power tools)
  • Luggage sets
  • Seasonal and holiday décor (small holiday decor should be put into “lots” to sell as a bundle.)

Examples of items we are NOT able to accept this year:

  • Clothing
  • Electronics
  • Miscellaneous small or single items (such as individual dishes, knick-knacks, etc.)

In the past, donations have sometimes resembled thrift store drop-offs, and while the generosity is appreciated, we simply don’t have the volunteer capacity to sort, price, and dispose of unsellable items. This new approach will help us steward everyone’s time and energy more effectively—and ultimately raise more funds.

New Donation Drop-Off Process

To help manage donations well, we are implementing specific drop-off times. A member of our trustees will be present to receive and review items:

  • Monday, May 11 | 5:00–7:00 PM
  • Tuesday, May 12 | 10:00 AM–1:00 PM
  • Wednesday, May 13 | 5:00–7:00 PM

If you need to arrange a different time, please contact Michelle Merchant at 414-333-7529 (call or text). Please do not leave items at the church outside of these times unless you have made prior arrangements.

Thank you for your understanding, your generosity, and your partnership in making this event successful. All sale proceeds will be for our Here for Good Fundraising Campaign